Distinguishing Biological Adaptation from Moral Desirability in Evolutionary Psychology
Distinguishes the strict Darwinian definition of "adaptation" — a heritable trait that increased ancestral reproductive success — from the folk conflation of adaptation with moral desirability, arguing that motivated reasoning leads people to want valued traits classified as adaptations and to deny adaptive status to traits perceived as unpleasant. Introduces and rebuts the "blank slate" hypothesis (that the mind lacks innate evolved structure) by identifying four psychological fears — of inequality, imperfectibility, determinism, and nihilism — that made it an ideological default, arguing each rests on conflating empirical claims about human nature with moral or political commitments. Situates this within evolutionary psychology's intersection with ethics and political theory.