The Four Ways of Knowing and the Crucial Experiment in the History of Science
Science is distinguished from other ways of knowing (divine authority, human authority) by relying on only two legitimate sources of knowledge: experimental observation and logic/reason, a framework traced to Francis Bacon's inductive method (Novum Organum, 1620), which replaced Aristotelian deduction from few observations with knowledge built from repeated, deliberately designed experiments. Central to this framework is the "crucial experiment" (experimentum crucis, from Latin crux/cross), an experiment specifically designed to decide between two competing hypotheses by proving one and disproving the other, exemplified historically by Newton's prism experiments distinguishing color as pre-existing within light versus color as produced by the prism. This is a topic in the history and philosophy of science / epistemology of the scientific method, foundational to how scientific claims are justified and distinguished from unsubstantiated assertion.